How To Manage Your Amazon Account Health

How to stay out or get out of trouble

by Auctiva.com staff writer
- May 01, 2025
Maintaining a healthy Amazon account is crucial for success on the platform. A healthy Amazon account not only increases your sales, it is also necessary if you want to remain an Amazon seller! We’ve put together these essential tips and strategies for monitoring and improving your Amazon account health. This guide will cover key steps you should take to keep your Amazon account healthy, such as Order Defect Rate (ODR), managing feedback and claims, shipping performance, and preparing effective Plans of Action (POAs) to correct any problem areas.

Check Your Amazon Dashboard Regularly

Treat your Amazon dashboard like it is your best friend. A true best friend gives you praise when you deserve it, but isn’t afraid to let you know when you’ve made a mistake or need to improve. If you listen carefully to what your Amazon dashboard is telling you and take action based on that feedback, then you will safeguard your seller account and set yourself up for success. There are five main areas of your dashboard that deserve your attention. Check your dashboard once a day at a minimum, and respond to all notifications as quickly as you can.

Order Defect Rate (ODR)

Having a low order defect rate is one of the best things you can do to keep your Amazon account healthy. Let’s take a look at some tips that will help you achieve this goal.

Negative Feedback/Reviews

Nobody likes to receive negative feedback. If you’re like most sellers your emotions can easily take over when the feedback is undeserved. However, the best way to handle negative feedback is the exact opposite. Start by putting your emotions aside and objectively evaluate the situation. Look at the feedback from the buyer’s point of view and try to understand where they are coming from - even if you disagree with it! Is there room for improvement in your processes? If this order had been handled differently could the negative feedback have been avoided? Not all negative feedback is a sign that you need to change how you handle your business, but sometimes it is. If there is a change that you can make to avoid this type of complaint in the future then seriously consider implementing that change.

 

After you have objectively and without emotion evaluated the negative feedback, if you still believe it was unwarranted, check to see if it qualifies for removal. Typically Amazon will only remove a negative review if it violates their Community Guidelines. If you know the feedback qualifies for removal, or even if you think that it might, then request that Amazon remove the feedback.

 

If the feedback does not qualify for removal then reply to it. The only emotion that you want to come across in your reply is empathy. This is not the time to argue or disagree with the customer. You are not only replying to this specific customer - you are also communicating with all of your potential customers that read the review and your reply. A measured reply will show them that you are engaged and will fix problems as they come up. Include in your reply any steps that you’ve taken to remedy the situation and prevent it from happening in the future.

A-to-Z Claims and Chargebacks

The best way to handle A-to-Z claims and chargebacks is to prevent them from happening at all. Even if you are completely in the right, the case can still be ruled against you. You run the risk of losing both the product and money if your customer wins the dispute, and disputes can take a great deal of time and effort to handle. The best solution might be to stretch your policies and give your customer more than you think they deserve to resolve the case before it is escalated to a claim or dispute.

 

Not all claims and disputes can be avoided. What do you do when they happen anyway, despite your best efforts? Some sellers make the mistake of setting them aside to deal with later. Responding to disputes is one of the least enjoyable parts of being a seller, and can seem less important than other necessary tasks. The best approach is to treat them as high impact issues that need both a quick and thoughtful response. This will increase your chances of winning and show that you care about your account health and treat it as a priority.

 

Disputes can be ruled against you even if you’ve done everything correctly with your reply. Sometimes you have the option to challenge a lost dispute. If you have that option then take advantage of it and use it. There is nothing to lose by challenging an A-to-Z claim that you have lost.

Keep Your Order Count High

Easier said than done, right? Every seller wants a high order count for obvious reasons. You might not know that a high order count can also help you keep a low order defect rate. For example, if you have 101 orders a month then this means you can only have one defective order to stay under your ODR of less than one percent. If you find yourself with a high ODR, then consider temporarily lowering the price of one or more of your items so that it is selling at cost. Pick a product that gets very few complaints and is usually well received by your customers. The profit for these orders will not be immediate dollars, but will pay off in the long term with the additional profitable sales you will get by keeping your Amazon account healthy.

Policy Compliance

Always take a look at any policy compliance notice that you get as quickly as possible. These are more common with certain selling categories and products, so if you’re lucky this won’t be something that you have to deal with. If you do get a policy compliance notice then review it immediately. The notice should include any impact to your Amazon account health and your options for next steps. The impact of these notices can range from none at all to account deactivation. Be sure to take action accordingly.

Shipping Performance

It is critical that you not only meet your customers’ shipping expectations but that you exceed them. This isn’t only about how quickly you get the package in the hands of the shipping carrier. It is also about your shipping carrier’s performance, which Amazon will hold you accountable for. Shipping speed and delivery time promises can be as impactful to your business as the prices of your products, and it can be tempting to be aggressive with your promises. When you get more aggressive with your promises you will need to pay very close attention to your performance and that of your shipping carrier. It might be necessary to scale back on your promises or even consider changing how you ship.

Keep Your Contact Information Accurate

This is an easy one with the potential of a massive impact to your Amazon account health. Be sure that your emergency contact phone number and email are accurate and current. Amazon does call about account health related issues and you want to be ready to take that call and show you are serious about fixing any problems. Be prepared to answer any questions that Amazon has and follow up accordingly.

Be Proactive and Communicate with Amazon

When there is a poor metric or some other issue that will impact or even has the slightest potential of impacting your Amazon account health, it is best to call Amazon or open a support case with them. In the call or message to Amazon include your plan to address and correct the issue. That way if your account gets into trouble because of this issue in the future there is a record showing that you have been proactive in resolving the issue. This can only help your case as it shows that you care about and manage account health issues when they arise.

Achieve Access To Amazon Account Health Assurance

Not everyone qualifies for Amazon’s Account Health Assurance (AHA) program. If you are a professional seller and you meet the qualifications, then use it! If there are changes that you can make to your business that will help you achieve AHA status then consider making those changes. This program helps you avoid account suspensions and gives you 72 hours to work with Amazon when issues come up.

Learn How To Write a Plan Of Action

There are many different formats and examples of Amazon Plans Of Action (POAs) that can be found with a quick internet search. In general you want to make sure your POA includes three main pieces of information.

     A detailed explanation of what happened. This should be data driven and void of emotion. It should include numbers, timeframes, and other concrete data. An example is “For the past 30 day period our account achieved a 1.5% order defect rate. This was driven by four negative feedbacks on SKU XYZ with ASIN 123456789.”

     The specific steps you have taken to remedy the situation. These steps should directly address the issue that happened. Be specific and concise with your reply. An example might start with “All four of the customers that left negative feedback on SKU XYZ were refunded in full the same day the negative feedback was received. In addition we have shipped them replacement products at no charge. The tracking information for the replacements is . . .”

     The specific plan that you have to prevent this problem from reoccurring. The plan should address the issue that happened and give specific actions on which you are committing to execute. An example might be “Our warehouse has inspected our entire stock of SKU XYZ and removed all products that are missing part #1234. In addition we have worked with our supplier to ensure this problem does not happen again in the future.”

Final Thoughts

Keeping your Amazon account healthy is an ongoing process that requires diligence and proactive management. Monitoring and responding to issues related to key metrics like your ODR, customer feedback, A-to-Z claims, and shipping performance is critical. Being ready to create a POA when issues do arise will allow you to respond quickly and efficiently. Do what you can to achieve AHA status and always be as proactive as possible when addressing current and potential issues with your Amazon account health. Good luck and happy selling!


About the Author

Auctiva staff writers constantly monitor trends and best practices of those selling on eBay and elsewhere online. They attend relevant training seminars and trade shows and regularly discuss the market with PowerSellers and other market experts.

Other Entries by this Author

Follow Us